In a memorandum dated November 10, 2026, USPTO Director John Squires announced that, effective November 16, 2026, he was formally returning merits-based reviews of inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) petitions to three-member panels of Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) administrative patent judges (APJs).
This policy marks a significant change to IPR and PGR institution procedure. Since October 2025, Director Squires has single-handedly exercised his authority under 35 U.S.C. § 314 to decide whether to institute or deny IPR and PGR proceedings based on both discretionary and non-discretionary (i.e., merits-based) factors. The Director’s unilateral exercise of such decision-making authority has driven down IPR and PGR institution rates significantly, from over 60% prior to October 2025 to about 35% now.
IPR and PGR institution reviews will now follow a two-stage process. First, as he has done over the past year, the Director will continue to review all IPR and PGR petitions to determine whether to deny them for discretionary reasons. Second, if the Director does not deny a petition for discretionary reasons, he will refer the petition to a three-member PTAB panel of APJs to determine whether the petition should be rejected on the merits. The memorandum notes that, if the petition is instituted, a new panel of APJs (not including any APJs assigned to the institution panel) will be assigned to conduct the subsequent IPR or PGR trial.
The November 10 memorandum provides the following clarification and guidance concerning the two-stage process.
Director review of discretionary considerations: The Director will continue to review IPR and PGR petitions based upon discretionary considerations, pursuant to the framework set forth in his Magnolia Technologies, Inc. v. Kurin, Inc., IPR2026-00097, Paper 17 (May 14, 2026) precedential decision. As explained in Magnolia, those discretionary considerations include (i) whether the patent challenged in the petition was or is the subject of a prior or parallel district court or USPTO proceeding; (ii) whether the petitioner has taken inconsistent positions in other proceedings; (iii) whether the petitioner is based in the United States; (iv) whether a substantial showing has been made that the examiner erred in issuing the challenged patent; and (v) whether the challenged patent has been in force for several years (i.e., “settled expectations”).
The Director will continue to issue summary notices, without opinion or comment, with respect to institution denials based upon discretionary considerations.
PTAB panel review of merits-based considerations: For purposes of institution, 35 U.S.C. §§ 314(a) and 324(a) require that IPR and PGR petitions, respectively, demonstrate a “reasonable likelihood” that the petitioner will prevail on at least one challenged claim, or that it is “more likely than not” that at least one challenged claim is unpatentable. The memorandum clarifies that those threshold institution standards are equivalent to the “reasonable likelihood” showing necessary to obtain a preliminary injunction, “and effectively require[] the petitioner to present a prima facie case justifying a rejection of the claim in a patent.”
Importantly, the memorandum instructs PTAB merits review panels to deny institution of an IPR or PGR petition not only if the petitioner fails to satisfy the “reasonable likelihood” or “more likely than not” standard with respect to one challenged claim, but also “[i]f a petitioner fails to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.” (emphasis added). And “if the arguments for and against unpatentability of a particular challenged claim are both reasonably supported when considering all of the evidence (i.e., the evidence and arguments are in equipoise), then, with respect to that particular challenged claim, the PTAB will not view the petitioner as having met the reasonable likelihood IPR standard, or the more likely than not PGR standard.”
Consistent with earlier 2026 Director decisions, the memorandum emphasizes that any prior art invalidity ground in an IPR or PGR petition must include “an understandable explanation of the element-by-element specifics of the patentability challenges, including an identification of particular portions of prior art on which the petitioner is relying,” and, conversely, that “merely pointing to a USPTO examiner’s findings is insufficient to explain where each element of the claim is found in the prior art.” A failure to comply with those specificity requirements warrants denial of institution.
The memorandum further clarifies that “a reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence, that the petitioner fails to meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims,” made either by the patent owner or by the PTAB panel itself, warrants denial of institution.
Last, although the memorandum notes that the Director will continue his current practice of issuing summary notices of discretionary institution denials without opinion, the same will not be true of institution denials by PTAB merits review panels. Rather, “[f]or any decision on institution that a PTAB panel issues, the panel will briefly address the merits-based considerations that the panel found important. The decision should set forth sufficient information showing that the petitioner has or has not met the appropriate standard at least as to one claim and one ground asserted in the petition but need not address every ground or argument.”