November 16, 2026

Timing Is Everything: When Employers May Enforce Arbitration Obligations Under the EFAA

5 min

Congress has sharply limited the use of mandatory arbitration in sexual harassment and sexual assault cases, but those limits have an important boundary.

The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) applies to arbitration agreements made before a dispute arises. It applies only to cases that relate to a sexual assault or sexual harassment disputes, and only at the election of the person bringing the claim. Specifically, the EFAA addresses pre-dispute arbitration agreements only, defined as "any agreement to arbitrate a dispute that had not yet arisen at the time of the making of the agreement."

It does not prevent parties from voluntarily agreeing to arbitrate after a dispute arises. That distinction is important—the law targets agreements made before a dispute exists, not arbitration itself. Recent cases are beginning to refine that distinction—and show why the timing of when a "dispute" actually arises can determine whether an arbitration agreement or provision is enforceable.

Recently, courts have faced other timing questions with respect to the EFAA. As we have previously written, the Second and Ninth Circuits addressed how the EFAA can allow employees to pursue an entire case—not just claims related to sexual assault and/or sexual harassment—in court. Other courts have recently weighed in on whether parties may still agree to arbitrate after a dispute has arisen and the reach of the EFAA to disputes that arose prior to its enactment. We address recent key rulings on these significant issues below.

Richards v. Silver: Post-Dispute Arbitration Clauses Are Enforceable

In Richards v. Silver, the plaintiff filed administrative charges with the EEOC asserting claims of sexual harassment and age discrimination. Subsequently, in May 2023, the parties executed a settlement agreement containing a robust arbitration clause. The clause provided that "any claim, action or proceeding relating to or arising out of this Agreement shall be exclusively brought, addressed and resolved via binding arbitration." As often happens, the parties got into disputes over the settlement later, with the plaintiff alleging that the employer had breached the confidentiality provisions of the settlement agreement. The employer moved to remand the case to state court or, alternatively, to dismiss the action, arguing that the arbitration provision was unenforceable under the EFAA. The court held that the arbitration clause was not a pre-dispute arbitration agreement and therefore was not subject to the EFAA. Accordingly, the arbitration clause was enforceable.

Richards reinforces that determining whether an arbitration agreement is truly "post-dispute" requires a fact-specific inquiry into when the parties became adverse. The occurrence of the underlying alleged misconduct is not necessarily enough. Courts examining the EFAA's timing provisions increasingly distinguish between when actionable conduct occurs or a claim accrues and when a "dispute" arises between the parties. The latter generally requires some manifestation of disagreement or adversity between them.

Castillo v. Altice USA, Inc.: The EFAA Does Not Apply Retroactively

A related timing question is whether the EFAA reaches claims that predate its enactment. In Castillo v. Altice USA, Inc., plaintiff brought claims against her employer of sexual harassment that occurred before March 3, 2022, the date on which President Biden signed the EFAA into law. Before the employer hired Castillo, the parties entered into an arbitration agreement on March 29, 2018. Castillo later asserted sexual harassment claims in court.

The employer moved to compel arbitration, but Castillo argued that the EFAA made the agreement unenforceable. While Castillo conceded that her claims accrued before the EFAA was enacted on March 3, 2022, she argued that the "dispute" did not arise until later. In its ruling, the court held that the EFAA did not relieve Castillo from her obligation to arbitrate her claims against her employer, stating, "because Castillo's dispute or claim arose or accrued prior to the enactment of the EFAA on March 3, 2022, the EFAA does not render unenforceable the otherwise applicable and binding Arbitration Agreement between the parties."

This case confirms that the EFAA does not apply retroactively. Under Castillo, the filing date of the complaint was not controlling. Instead, the court considered when the dispute arose or the claim accrued. We can deduce from Castillo that where the alleged conduct and the resulting claim both predate March 3, 2022, the EFAA generally will not prohibit arbitration. Employers should note, however, that a claim based on conduct continuing past that date, such as a hostile work environment claim, may accrue after enactment and fall within the coverage of the EFAA.

Post-Dispute Arbitration Remains an Option Under the EFAA

The EFAA changed the enforceability of mandatory pre-dispute arbitration in sexual assault and sexual harassment cases, but it did not eliminate arbitration as a forum for those disputes. Employers considering post-dispute arbitration should make the chronology and the parties' consent to arbitration clear. The agreement should identify the existing dispute with reasonable specificity, state that the dispute has already arisen, describe the claims featured in the dispute, and confirm that the parties are agreeing to arbitration after the dispute arose.

Those drafting decisions do not themselves determine whether the EFAA will apply; a court will always conduct a fact-intensive inquiry. They can, however, reduce later uncertainty about the claims and disputes the parties intended to arbitrate and whether the agreement was directed to a current controversy rather than an unknown future claim. Employers should also account for applicable state-law restrictions and contract defenses, which may impose requirements beyond the federal EFAA.

Employers with questions about the application and implications of the EFAA or general arbitration provisions or agreements can contact the author of this article or any attorney in Venable's Labor and Employment Group.

The author thanks law clerk Emily K. Lombardi for her assistance in writing this alert.