In Lion Elastomers LLC (Lion Elastomers III) the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) reversed a Biden-era precedent for the standard used to evaluate employee misconduct during protected union activity, marking the first such reversal of employee-friendly precedent under the new Trump-appointed NLRB majority.
How Did the NLRB's Employee Discipline Standard Evolve?
Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) provides employees with “the right to engage in…concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection.” This provision potentially limits the right of employers to terminate an employee who engaged in misconduct during protected activity—such as the grievance process. In Lion Elastomers III, the board returned to an earlier, employer-friendly standard for evaluating whether misconduct during the course of protected activity violates the NLRA.
In 1980, the NLRB decision in Wright Line established a burden-shifting test to determine whether an employer’s discipline of an employee was motivated by the employee’s exercise of their protected rights. Under the Wright Line test, the NLRB’s general counsel bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that the employee engaged in protected activity, the employer knew it, and the protected activity was a motivating factor in the employee’s discipline. After establishing that prima facie case, the burden shifts to the employer to show it would have taken the same action even in the absence of the employee’s protected activity.
Eventually, the NLRB strayed from the consistent application of the Wright Line test and developed situationally specific standards for employee misconduct, resulting in various standards for determining whether an employer violated an employee’s Section 7 rights by disciplining them while they were engaged in protected activity. One such standard, announced in Atlantic Steel, is a four-factor test that considers the place of the discussion, the subject matter, the nature of the employee’s outburst, and whether the outburst was provoked by an employer’s unfair labor practice.
In 2020, the NLRB considered Lion Elastomers LLC (Lion Elastomers I), which concerned whether the employer violated the employee’s Section 7 rights by threatening to discharge the employee for making a charged statement to his manager during a grievance meeting. There, the NLRB applied the Atlantic Steel standard and found that the employee’s conduct at issue was protected. Lion Elastomers I was appealed to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.
While Lion Elastomers I was on appeal and during the first Trump administration in 2020, the NLRB issued its decision in General Motors and returned to the application of the Wright Line test. This did not last long, as the NLRB under the Biden administration tried to overturn General Motors in Lion Elastomers LLC (Lion Elastomers II) by returning to the four-factor Atlantic Steel standard; Lion Elastomers II was also appealed to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Fifth Circuit vacated the decision in Lion Elastomers II and remanded the case back to the NLRB to apply the Wright Line test as used in General Motors.
What Is the Current Wright Line Standard?
In its third decision in the Lion Elastomers trilogy, the NLRB ruled that the Fifth Circuit’s decision vacating Lion Elastomers II effectively restored the NLRB’s decision in General Motors. Therefore, the Wright Line test, as applied in General Motors, is the current test for determining whether an employee’s conduct loses NLRA protection. Put simply, as it stands now, the NLRB’s general counsel bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that the employee engaged in protected activity, the employer knew it, and the protected activity was a motivating factor in the employee’s discipline. Then the burden shifts to the employer to establish that it would have taken the same action even in the absence of the protected activity. (Unlike Atlantic Steel, which focused on the nature and place of the employee’s actions.)
What does this mean for employers?
The return of the General Motors decision means that discipline of an employee who engages in profane or abusive conduct during the course of activity protected under the NLRA has become considerably easier to defend. However, as with any employment action that may be challenged, employers should be sure to apply discipline related to profane or abusive conduct consistently and to effectively document the behavior and reasons for discipline.
In addition, with a Trump-appointed majority on the NLRB, more employer-friendly rulings overturning NLRB precedent set under the Biden-era NLRB could follow.
Employers are encouraged to review their policies regarding employee discipline. Employers with questions about this decision, its implications, or its application to specific employment practices are encouraged to contact the authors of this article or any attorney in Venable’s Labor and Employment Group.