Regulation II’s long-standing debit card interchange fee cap has been dealt a significant blow. On October 26, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed a district court judgment vacating the current 21-cent debit card interchange fee cap under Regulation II. In Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the court held that the cap improperly included fixed costs that were not specific to individual debit card transactions, exceeding the Federal Reserve’s authority under the Durbin Amendment.
The decision could materially affect the economics of debit card programs for banks, payment networks, fintech companies, and merchants. It does not, however, immediately change the interchange fees charged today. The opinion will not take effect until the Eighth Circuit issues its mandate, making its decision effective. At that point, the district court’s order throwing out the Federal Reserve’s existing interchange cap becomes effective, and the Federal Reserve will have to develop a new interchange fee structure. The Federal Reserve may also seek rehearing or Supreme Court review.
The Durbin Amendment
When a debit card is used to pay for a transaction, the merchant's bank generally pays an interchange fee to the bank that issued the payor’s debit card. Payment networks set the applicable rates, and merchants generally bear those costs through the fees charged by their acquiring banks or payment providers.
The Durbin Amendment to the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act requires interchange fees received by covered debit card issuers to be "reasonable and proportional" to the issuer's cost with respect to the transaction. In determining that “reasonable and proportional” cost, it directs the Federal Reserve to distinguish between the incremental cost incurred by the issuer in authorizing, clearing, or settling particular debit card transactions, which must be considered, and other costs that are not specific to particular debit card transactions, which may not be considered.
The fee restrictions generally apply to issuers that, together with their affiliates, have at least $10 billion in assets. Regulation II currently permits an interchange fee of (i) 21 cents per transaction plus (ii) five basis points multiplied by the transaction amount. An issuer that satisfies the regulation's fraud-prevention standards may receive an additional one cent per transaction.
This framework has been subject to potential change. In 2023, the Federal Reserve proposed—but has not adopted—a lower cap of 14.4 cents per transaction, four basis points multiplied by the transaction amount, and a potential 1.3-cent fraud-prevention adjustment. The proposal would have retained the Federal Reserve's existing approach to allowable costs while updating the amounts using more recent issuer data.
Corner Post Decision
Corner Post (a merchant) challenged Regulation II under the Administrative Procedure Act, arguing that the Federal Reserve had exceeded its statutory authority by including costs that were not specific to particular debit card transactions in its interchange fee cap.
After reaching the Supreme Court on a statute of limitations issue, the case returned to the district court. On remand, the district court held that the interchange fee standard exceeded the Federal Reserve's statutory authority and vacated the fee cap, but stayed its decision pending appeal. The Eighth Circuit affirmed this holding.
The Eighth Circuit's analysis focused on four issues:
- No deference to the Federal Reserve. Applying Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, the court independently interpreted the Durbin Amendment. Congress authorized the Federal Reserve to issue regulations, but that delegation did not permit the agency to disregard statutory limits on the costs it could consider. In short, courts, not agencies, decide where Congress's delegation ends.
- "Incremental cost" means marginal cost. The court interpreted incremental cost as the additional cost an issuer incurs to process one more debit card transaction. In the court's view, the relevant unit is a particular transaction, not the issuer's overall debit card program.
- Fixed costs generally cannot be included. Costs that do not change when an issuer processes another transaction are not marginal costs. The court identified hardware, software, labor, network connectivity, and fraud-detection systems as costs that may be fixed, depending on how an issuer pays for them. The same expense could be fixed for one bank and incremental for another. For example, an internally operated fraud system may involve fixed costs, while an outsourced service priced per transaction may create incremental costs.
- A single uniform cap did not reflect the statutory framework. The court emphasized that Congress directed the Federal Reserve to establish "standards," in the plural, rather than simply select one number without the required cost analysis.
Importantly, the court did not hold that each interchange fee must precisely equal the marginal cost of each individual transaction. The Federal Reserve may use a proxy, potentially including average variable cost, if the proxy bears a reasonable relationship to issuers' marginal costs.
What Happens Now?
The Federal Reserve may seek panel or en banc rehearing and, ultimately, Supreme Court review. A related case, Linney's Pizza, LLC v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, is pending before the Sixth Circuit. The district court in that case upheld Regulation II, and the Sixth Circuit heard oral argument on October 22, 2026. Courts outside the Eighth Circuit are not bound by Corner Post, so the Sixth Circuit may reach a different conclusion. If the Sixth Circuit affirms, it would create a circuit split with the Eighth Circuit and strengthen the case for Supreme Court review.
Conclusion
The Eighth Circuit's decision is a significant rejection of the Federal Reserve's 2011 interchange methodology, but it is not the final word on debit interchange pricing. Covered issuers and their program partners should pay attention to the Sixth Circuit’s decision in Linney's Pizza and consider evaluating the contractual, economic, accounting, and operational effects of alternative fee structures.